Blog

Total Shoulder Replacement Myths

Posted on 06-12-2026 in Shoulder & Total Shoulder Replacement by Dr. Chris O'Grady

In recent years, advances in medical technology have debunked preconceived notions about total shoulder replacement. Dr. Chris O'Grady, an experienced and skilled Board Certified Orthopedic Surgeon, compiled 5 common myths about total shoulder replacement below.

1. Shoulder replacements do not provide good results.

False. Shoulder replacements are extremely successful, especially for individuals with osteoarthritis.

2. I am too young to have a shoulder replacement/I am too old to have a joint replacement surgery.

No matter what your age, if you have chronic pain in your shoulder, you may benefit from a total shoulder replacement surgery. As long as you are healthy enough to have surgery, there is no reason to continue living with pain. It is never too soon or too late to seek treatment that could provide you freedom from pain.

3. Following surgery, I will have permanent limitations.

False. With proper therapy, the majority of Dr. O’Grady’s patients achieve a higher level of function than they had before surgery (with less pain).  Patients are advised to refrain from frequent heavy lifting in order to minimize the wear and tear on the replacement. Even with this restriction, most patients who desire to return to an active lifestyle do so rather quickly.  Most patients return to a pain-free existence and many return to sports like tennis, golf, swimming, bowling, fishing, hunting, kayaking, surfing, etc

4. Only patients who have severe arthritis can have their shoulder replaced.

False. Although total shoulder replacements are done for individuals who have arthritis, this procedure is also used to address fractures, congenital shoulder defects, and massive irreparable rotator cuff tears.

5. Shoulder replacement implants are not reliable or a long-lasting solution.

False. Research indicates that the life of a shoulder implant is substantial with 93 percent lasting 10 years and 87 percent lasting 15 years.

Individuals suffering from shoulder pain who reside in the Northwest Florida area should contact Florida Bone & Joint Specialists today. Dr. Christopher O’Grady is an Orthopaedic Surgeon who is dedicated to helping those experiencing shoulder pain. Seeking treatment is critical to ensuring the damage occurring to the shoulder is addressed. Click below to schedule an appointment at North Florida Bone & Joint Specialists.

Save or share this information:

Check out some of our related posts:

Safe Toys & Gifts Month

December is National Safe Toys & Gifts Month, and as we go about our holiday shopping, it's important to remember the impact those presents can have on the well-being of the children in our lives. A recently released report by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) indicated that nearly 210,000 children were treated in hospital emergency rooms for a toy-related injury in 2022. The annual CPSC report also provided the following illuminating statistics:

Read More
Orthopaedic Injury Care Anytime

North Florida Bone & Joint Specialists is excited to announce the availability of the Hurt! smartphone app and the web-based version, accessible on a desktop device. This revolutionary new resource uses human-to-human interaction to connect patients with acute orthopaedic injuries to an expert Hurt! Care Navigator in real-time, 24/7, 365 days a year.

Read More
The Right Shoes

Footwear serves several useful functions, including protecting our feet, cushioning our body weight, providing comfort and, of course, adding a fashionable element to our wardrobe choices. However, selecting the proper footwear can also make a difference in your overall foot health. As you consider those fun new kicks, we encourage you to be mindful of how the right type of shoe can help you avoid injury or further exacerbate existing foot and ankle conditions. Specifically, ill-fitting shoes can be painful and cause issues such as bunions, hammertoes, plantar fasciitis, Lisfranc injuries and more.

Read More
Back to the Blog